New York Jets: Making the Case to keep Mike Maccagnan (22-12)

Crazier things have happened, but Todd Bowles will likely be replaced as head coach of the New York Jets. What about GM Mike Maccagnan? Here’s why he needs to stay.


No two NFL jobs are created equal, with a position on the New York Jets being harder than most. The media and fans are unforgiving, ownership is often lacking, and a history of stink remains around the green and white. Thankfully, the Jets are re-branding in 2019, hoping to shed the bad energy surrounding the current logo and design. Will the team itself rise to meet this new age of football?

Ownership hit a minor refresh last year. The coaching staff is about to get another new look, hopefully for the final time in the near future. What needs to stay the same is Mike Maccagnan. New York’s general manager is two-thirds of the way through his rebuilding plan and the Jets’ roster is currently an open book. The team must allow Maccagnan to finish writing his story, because a new man in charge will want to tear out the pages. This is foolish, considering the groundwork already set by the current GM.

MORE BUZZCHOMP: New York Jets Holiday Wish List

My instincts told me Maccagnan had done a good job with the Jets, above average and on the path to sustainable success. But we must look at all of the moves he made, in order to properly place a vote of confidence in his body of work. did an excellent job of grading every prominent move Mike Maccagnan made with the Jets, but don’t let their specific opinions sway you. Simply count up the hits and misses. Below are the details on his body of work.


Beef Up Your Home Gym with this All-In-One Weight Bench


First, I’ll give you Maccagnan’s tally in terms of hits and misses. Picks from rounds 3 – 7 are considered a single hit or miss, while each player drafted in rounds one and two are considered individually. Then I’ll dive into the milestones that placed me on the Maccagnan bandwagon. Why do the winning moves overshadow the major misses? Our current team core holds the answer.

Maccagnan’s Tally as New York Jets GM (Hits-Misses): 22-12


Noteworthy Winning Moves:

Brandon Marshall (2015)
Buster Skrine (2015)
Ryan Fitzpatrick (2015)
Demario Davis (2017)
Jermaine Kearse (2017)
Josh McCown (2017, 2018)
Teddy Bridgewater (2018)

Leonard Williams (Round 1, 2015)
Darron Lee (Round 1, 2016)
Jamal Adams (Round 1, 2017)
Marcus Maye (Round 2, 2017)
Sam Darnold (Round 1, 2018)
Notable 7th Round Picks (WR Charone Peake, P Lachlan Edwards)
Notable 6th Round Picks (RB Eli McGuire, CB Parry Nickerson)

Major Misses:

Darrelle Revis (2015)
Antonio Cromartie (2015)
Ryan Fitzpatrick (2016)
Terrelle Pryor (2018)
Spencer Long (2018)

Devin Smith (Round 2, 2015)
Christian Hackenberg (Round 2, 2016)
Bad 4th Round Picks (QB Bryce Petty, WR Chad Hansen)
Bad 3rd Round Picks (OLB Lorenzo Mauldin, WR ArDarius Stewart)


There are a few major takeaways from Mike Maccagnan’s body of work. He has nailed every first round pick and half of his second round picks. Maccagnan actually missed on his second round picks early in his tenure, but then completely reversed the trend. He’s also crushed the late rounds of the draft, but completely whiffed in rounds three and four every time.

ALSO ON BUZZCHOMP: 10 Best Gifts Under $25

Overall, his big free agent signings have all worked out. I say this because its easy to excuse several of the major misses. Signing Revis and Cromartie in an attempt to recreate the defensive backfield which the Jets dominated with a few years earlier is understandable. Plus, Revis is and was a Jets legend. Re-signing Fitzpatick also made sense, despite the manner in which the process got screwed up. This year’s free agents have not worked out, but injuries are impossible to predict. I did not include Trumaine Johnson on the list of misses because he has played well since finally getting healthy.


When you nail the biggest draft picks and biggest long shots in the draft, while succeeding more often than not in free agency and with trades, you have done well. Mike Maccagnan has done well. He attempted to go all the way, then was forced to quick start a full rebuild. The young and successful core of the New York Jets is a testament to his success. Most of the pieces which don’t fit are about to become free agents. Many of the players left off this list are solid contributors with red flags, like Robbie Anderson and Quincy Enunwa. Keep Mike Maccagnan and let him finish what he started.


Connect With Our Writer:

Dan Salem is Lead Editor, Staff Writer, and Featured Host at BuzzChomp. He’s a Staff Writer for NFL Spinzone, as well as an Actor, Writer, Director and Producer. Get lost in his Youtube comedy channel PillowTalk TV. Follow him on Twitter, Facebook, Google+, and Instagram.



New York Jets Photo Credits: and Sporting News

BuzzChomp is an affiliate for products and services recommended herein. Please read our Full Disclaimer for further information on affiliate programs and opportunities.

Click to comment

You're Awesome! Subscribe and Comment Below

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

To Top