new york jets new york giants
Buzz

New York Giants and Jets Week 10 in ONE WORD

Getty Images and AP Photo/Adam Hunger

Lousy… ONE word describes the results of New York Jets and New York Giants week ten games. Followed by a few more words, because this is a blog, not a sound byte.

Prepare for the intense sports debate that only sibling rivalry can conjure. Seesaw Sports, where Dan Salem and Todd Salem throw down on the NFL, MLB, NBA and more. Only on BuzzChomp. Two brothers from New York yell, scream and debate sports.

 

After Week 10 of the NFL season, New York teams are now 7-11-1 collectively. Actually 15-12-1 if you count Buffalo, but we do not count Buffalo around these parts. The New York Jets and Giants were both lousy in week 10, but for different reasons. Ugh!

New York Jets Week 10 in ONE WORD: WATCH NOW – Just ONE Word Only

How competent (or incompetent) are the New York Jets this season? Enough to keep things close most weeks, but not enough to win. Can the New York Giants win their division? Seems like it. Todd loves the Giants and Dan loves the Jets. They both must take the proverbial podium and speak truth into the microphone. Also proverbial.

New York Jets and Giants Week 10

 

new york jets new york giants
nfl.com

 

Is there anything the New York Giants do well as a team?

Todd Salem: With a chance to put real distance between themselves and the rest of the division, the Giants crumbled on Thursday night. John Harbaugh coached overly conservative, and it cost his team the game. The defense couldn’t get to Jayden Daniels all night, and it cost the team the game. Cam Skattebo couldn’t get a first down to run out the clock, and it cost his team the game. Jordan Stout had his first bad punt of the season, and it cost his team the game. Dominic Zvada missed yet another field goal, and it cost his team the game. Malik Nabers proved the haters right, had a crucial fumble, and cost his team the game.

Compartmentalized, any of these mistakes could have been overcome. Heck, ALL of them could have been overcome if the refs didn’t blow a late pass interference call on Deonte Banks. Nevertheless, this one hurts. And seeing so many facets come up short made me really think, is there anything this team does really well? 

Despite Harbaugh’s late-game decision-making in this one, I think the team is well coached. Despite the game plan against Daniels, I do think the pass rush is a strength. Skattebo had a really solid game, right on the heels of the team essentially handing him the reins by not trading for a back at the trade deadline. You know I love Stout; even the best punter in the league is allowed a misfire. Nabers is elite. Zvada…might not be in the NFL next year. Okay, so not everything can be flipped positively.

Fandom is Year Round: Exclusive NFL Shirts of Your Favorite STARS

But overall, it feels like there are a number of things New York can hang its hat on. So why is every game they play close and hanging in the balance until the very end? Why have seven of their nine contests been one-score games?

Is it too cliched to say because that’s the nature of the NFL? We know the Giants are not a great team. They are playing with a third-string quarterback, minus their most accomplished defender, with everyone playing for the first time together under this new regime. Great teams blow people out and hope to at least break even in one-score games. But good teams, which NY certainly is, just need more luck; luck with the schedule, luck with opponents making mistakes, etc. They won’t get those blowout wins, so every week feels harrowing.

Nationally, people see the Giants’ record, the absence of Dart, and assume a “better” team is going to surpass them at some point. First, there may not be a better team in the NFC East this year anyway. But second, I think the Giants are a good team that does a lot of things really well, hence the success. They just aren’t great at anything.

More BuzzChomp: Watch the thriller ‘Alone’ Before Your Fear Takes Control

Dan Salem: The Giants are pretty good almost everywhere, which on average is more than enough to beat teams with a weakness. New York doesn’t have a glaring weakness themselves, hence every game is close. But they also don’t have a dominating strength, hence they need luck to favor them in wins or need to play mistake free. They did not play mistake free against Washington and lost.

When their opponent makes more mistakes, the Giants have won. This is common sense, but the NFL is truly a cluster of slightly above average and slightly below average teams this season, with several outliers in each direction. New York is above average and should keep winning as long as they stay aggressive and limit mistakes. 

To answer the question, no, the Giants are not great at anything. But they will make the playoffs as long as coach Harbaugh throws out that conservative BS that lost them the game against Washington. If you can’t get one yard to win the game, you don’t deserve to win. New York lost last week because of this. Nine wins still feels likely, but the Commanders game was a wake up call. Its time for the Giants to get hungry and start feasting on their opponents.

 

nfl 2025
Getty Images
nfl 2025
Getty Images

Best Workout Gear: Browse Mandi’s Latest Videos!

Wear Your Fandom: NFL Superstar T-Shirts Designed by the FANS

 

 

Do we need to see any more Geno Smith?

Todd Salem: To this point in the season, Geno Smith has not been the problem for the Jets. He had some really good games, and it never felt like he was hampering the offense. In Week 10, Smith played somewhat poorly against a previously holey defense, including missing a wide open Adonai Mitchell on the opening drive and missing Garrett Wilson downfield a drive later. He got hurt to start the second half, tried to come back in later on, and couldn’t last. The team has already announced that Smith will be back in the lineup if he’s healthy in Week 11, but should he?

Smith was always a bridge quarterback for this team: a veteran to hold down the fort and hopefully breed offensive success with the young guys while the front office waits for the QB class of 2027. That remains the case now, except we have more information.

New York Giants Week 10 in ONE WORD: WATCH NOW – Just ONE Word Only

We know the team sits at 2-8, primed for a great pick in the draft. We know the offense never took off with Smith despite the legit talent. We know the team currently has a rookie QB on roster that they know nothing about (in terms of game action). Does that change the math for you? 

I can see both sides of the argument. On one hand, what is the reason to play Smith? The team isn’t going anywhere and has an intriguing, athletic QB in Cade Klubnik that they should want to evaluate.

On the other hand, what was the reason to sign Smith to begin with? The reason was to lead an offense and hope the team finds success. That hasn’t always been the case this year, but they were only trailing by four against Buffalo when Smith departed (trailing only by five when he departed the second time). If the coaching staff thinks Smith is still the best option to help develop the likes of Kenyon Sadiq, Mason Taylor, Mitchell, etc. then he needs to be in there. Also, if they are hoping to grab another win or two for pride’s sake, and to maybe attempt to save Aaron Glenn’s job, obviously Smith is the one who should be playing.

Exclusive Prices on BuzzChomp: NFL Superstar T-Shirts Designed by FANS

Dan Salem: I like what I saw from Klubnik, but he’s obviously a rookie and there is no point in rushing him onto the field before his decision-making improves and his ability to slow the game down for himself improves. That being said, Klubnik faced one of the best teams in the NFL, Buffalo, and would likely play very well against the very worst team next week, the Chargers. Even so, Smith needs to remain the starter if healthy.

It sends a poor message to the team if you bench your starting quarterback while he is playing well and gives you the best chance to win. The Raiders and Cardinals both traded theirs away, achieving the same result with more gains. Since the Jets did not trade Smith, which I believe was the right decision, he must remain the starter. Only in the final two weeks does it make sense to “hand over” the offense to your rookie quarterback.

The Jets are rebuilding and Smith is a key component to building a winning offense. Klubnik could actually be a solid quarterback, which is pretty cool, but he isn’t going to do much for this offense right now. Furthermore, the entire New York team desperately needs a few more wins to feel good about next season and the team being built. It’s obvious the defense is incomplete, but the offense has actually shown promise. I’m losing faith in the entire coaching staff, because they have not been able to address their glaring weaknesses. But Smith has been good. He’s the ‘hot hand’ in a room full of luke warm fingers.

 

 

Meet our Sports Writers:

Dan Salem is Lead Editor and Co-owner of BuzzChomp. He’s an award winning Actor, Director and Producer. Visit M Square Productions for his film work, or get lost in his old-school comedy on Pillow Talk TV. You can follow him on X, TikTok and Instagram. His latest film ‘Alone’ is now on Amazon.

Todd Salem is a Staff Writer and Contributing Editor at BuzzChomp. He’s also a champion of fantasy football and fantasy baseball, dominating leagues for over two decades. Comment below on his unfiltered opinions.

New York Jets and New York Giants Week 10 – This Is The End

Photo Credits: jetsxfactor.com via Getty Images and twincities.com (AP Photo/Adam Hunger)

BuzzChomp is an affiliate for products and services recommended herein. Please read our Full Disclaimer for further information on affiliate programs and opportunities.

New York Giants and Jets Week 10 in ONE WORD
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Latest

To Top