Numb to the Jets and crying over the Giants, but at least our ATS picks are subpar. Your best picks ATS for NFL Week 5 in the 3 Man Booth NFL Podcast.
These may be the WORST picks ATS for NFL Week 5, because our record is piss poor. Nine great picks, we hope, because we almost always end with a winning record. LOCK of the week is Giants over Saints. Rams over 49ers (loser). Cowboys over Jets. Eagles keep winning, plus Titans keep losing. Your NFL Week 5 Best Picks Against the Spread.
NFL Week 5 Best Picks ATS: Watch Now

2025 NFL Record Picking ATS:
Dan (5-7-0) – The Optimist
Bud (5-7-0) – The Pessimist
Phil (3-9-0) – The Realist
Numb to the New York Jets in Week 5: Watch Now

Welp, when your New York Jets fumble on the one yard line and you AREN’T surprised, that’s when you are a true Jets fan. We’re NUMB to this team because they keep making the same mistakes over and over and over. HOW is defense the issue now? HOW!?
No Nice Things for New York Giants in Week 5: Watch Now

Jaxson Dart makes EVERY game more winnable for the New York Giants, but now he has no weapons on offense. Nabers was the team’s best player and the Giants just CANT have nice things! He’s gone and SOMEONE must replace him. Dart can’t succeed without a passing game threat.
Time will tell if the optimist (Dan), the pessimist (Bud), or the realist (Phil) is right. Here’s hoping the games are fun to watch!
Your ‘3 Man Booth‘ is the only sports talk show that’s 100% football, straight out of the fan’s mouth. Dan Salem with Phil and Bud. Comment with your thoughts on the New York Jets and New York Giants. Will our suffering continue? Bud’s a pessimist, but will he once again be uncomfortably optimistic this season? Unlikely. Phil and Dan attempt optimism, but its so darn hard with these two football teams.
More BuzzChomp: Alone Movie Will Twist You Up, Scare You To The Bone
Whose your favorite NFL team? What’s your favorite way to watch? Let us know and be sure to check out BuzzChomp on Instagram for all of this show and more.

Buffalo Football T-Shirt (BB) In JOSH We TRUST Unisex heavyweight t-shirt
Unofficial Buffalo (BB) heavyweight t-shirt because in Josh we TRUST! Its all in this year in Buffalo. With B Mafia on the sleeve, you’re ready to roll this football season! Let your t-shirt do the talking and move along. For the men and women in your life, there’s only one man in charge of this team.
Meet our Hosts:
Dan Salem is Lead Editor and Co-owner of BuzzChomp. He’s an award winning Actor, Director and Producer. Visit M Square Productions for his film work, or get lost in his old-school comedy on Pillow Talk TV. You can follow him on X, TikTok and Instagram. His latest film ‘Alone’ is now on Amazon.
Phil Sember is Chief Degenerate Officer (CDO) at BuzzChomp. He’s co-host of our 3 Man Booth NFL talk show, as well as the View From Section 323 NFL podcast. He’s an avid New York Giants and New York Knicks fan. Follow him on X and Instagram.
Buddy Seamon is a contributing writer at BuzzChomp. He’s co-host of our 3 Man Booth NFL talk show, as well as the View From Section 323 NFL podcast. He’s an avid New York sports fan, rooting for the Yankees, Rangers and Jets. You can follow him on Instagram.
NFL Week 5 Photo Credits: bigblueview.com via Getty Images and the NFL
